Blog / Agent Orange

Federal Appeals Court Gives Big Win to Blue Water Veterans

Although the Vietnam War ended nearly a half-century ago, many veterans who served in that conflict continue to suffer from the effects. For example, many veterans are still dealing with their exposure to the toxic herbicide known as Agent Orange. In 1991, Congress adopted the Agent Orange Act, which created a legal presumption of a “service connection” for veterans who developed certain diseases while serving in Vietnam. In plain English, the law assumes that if a Vietnam veteran later developed a listed disease, it was assumed to be the result of Agent Orange exposure, unless there was “affirmative evidence” to the contrary.

No Legal Distinction Between Inland, Offshore Territorial Waters of Vietnam

The Agent Orange Act specifically covers military personnel who “served in the Republic of Vietnam” between January 1962 and May 1975. The “Republic of Vietnam” refers to what was formerly called South Vietnam. According to a recent decision by a federal appeals court, the Republic of Vietnam included not just the land territory and internal waters of former South Vietnam, but also its offshore waters.

More to the point, the Court determined the Agent Orange Act covers veterans who served aboard ships but who never physically set foot in Vietnam. The plaintiff, in this case, Procopio v. Wilkie, served aboard the U.S.S. Intrepid from 1964 to 1967 while a member of the U.S. Navy. In the summer of 1966, the Navy deployed the Intrepid to the offshore waters of the Republic of Vietnam.

Nearly 30 years later, the plaintiff developed diabetes mellitus and prostate cancer, both of which are known conditions related to Agent Orange exposure. The plaintiff sought benefits under the Agent Orange Act. The VA denied the plaintiff’s request, however, on the grounds that was never present “on the landmass or the inland waters of Vietnam during service.”

The plaintiff appealed the VA’s decision to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit in Washington, DC. On January 29, 2019, the Court held by a vote of 9-2 that the VA’s reading of the law was incorrect. There was no dispute the law covered veterans who “served in the Republic of Vietnam.” Contrary to the VA’s position, the “Republic of Vietnam” also included its offshore territorial waters.

This is not exactly a surprise to anyone who understands the basics of international law. Under a 1982 United Nations convention, the “territorial waters” of a given sovereign state extends up to 12 nautical miles (roughly 13.8 miles) from the low-water mark of the country’s shoreline. Anything within this 12-nautical mile zone is therefore considered part of the country’s territory, the same as any landmass or internal waters (such as rivers).

Given this, the Court here concluded that service onboard a naval vessel parked within the Republic of Vietnam’s territorial waters was, for all intents and purposes, “in the Republic of Vietnam.” The plaintiff was therefore “entitled to a presumption of service connection for his prostate cancer and diabetes mellitus.”

Speak with a Dedicated Veterans Benefits Lawyer Today

The Federal Circuit’s decision is welcome news for a number of “blue water” veterans who served on offshore vessels during the Vietnam War and developed Agent Orange-related complications as a result. If you need assistance from a qualified veterans benefits lawyer in pursuing a claim related to Agent Orange, contact The Comerford Law Office, LLC today to schedule a free consultation.

Posted in:

Related Posts

Denied VA Benefits for Agent Orange Exposure? Here’s How to Appeal

At Comerford Law Office, we understand just how frustrating and overwhelming it is to see your claims for VA benefits denied, especially when they involve illnesses linked to Agent Orange exposure. For many veterans, these benefits are not merely financial—they are a recognition of your sacrifices and a path to healthcare, stability, and dignity. If your claim for Agent Orange-related compensation has been denied, know this—you are not alone, and you don’t have to fight this battle alone. At Comerford Law Office, we are here to help you navigate the appeals process and fight for the benefits you deserve. Understanding Agent Orange and Its Effects Agent Orange was a herbicide used during the Vietnam War to defoliate forests and expose enemy hiding spots. Unfortunately, it also exposed thousands of US service members to harmful chemicals that have been linked to various health conditions, including certain cancers and other chronic illnesses. In 1991, Congress passed a law acknowledging the link between Agent Orange exposure and these medical issues, making veterans eligible for compensation and healthcare from the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA). Common Reasons for Denial Before starting the appeals process, it helps to understand why claims are often denied. At times, the VA may argue that you didn’t sufficiently prove exposure to Agent Orange or that your illness isn’t on the presumptive list of conditions acknowledged by the VA. Other denials hinge on inadequate medical documentation, errors in claims processing, or a failure to establish an undeniable connection between your military service and your diagnosis. While these denials may seem disheartening, they’re far from the end of the road. A Guide to the Appeals Process If your benefits claim has been denied, the VA provides several appeals options. Here’s how you can move forward effectively: Choose the Right Appeal Type – After a denial, you have three primary pathways to appeal, depending on the specifics of your situation. Higher-Level Review – This option involves requesting a senior claim reviewer to reexamine your case without any new evidence. If you suspect a clear claim processing error, this pathway may be your best bet. Supplemental Claim – If new and relevant evidence—like updated medical records or expert opinions—has come to light, a Supplemental Claim is the most appropriate route. Board of Veterans’ Appeals – For cases requiring further scrutiny, you can appeal directly to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals. You can select a direct review (no new evidence), submit new evidence, or opt for a hearing with a Veterans Law Judge. Meet Critical Deadlines – Deadlines are vital in the appeals process. You have one year from the date of your denial letter to file for a Higher-Level Review or Board Appeal. Missing this window means your only avenue is filing a Supplemental Claim, which requires new evidence. Gather Strong Evidence – Documentation is your strongest ally. Start by collecting thorough records that link your diagnosis to Agent Orange exposure. This may include medical evidence detailing your illness, proof of service records indicating you were in Vietnam or other designated areas, and expert witness statements if your condition is not on the VA’s presumptive list. Avoid Common Pitfalls – Omitting documentation, missing deadlines, or failing to address specific VA concerns can significantly weaken your case. Working with an experienced attorney ensures every element of your appeal is presented effectively, leaving no room for error. Tips for Strengthening Your Case Build a Timeline of Service and Diagnosis: Clearly outline your military service, including dates and locations, to highlight when and where Agent Orange exposure likely occurred. Know the Presumptive Conditions List: Familiarize yourself with conditions that the VA links to Agent Orange, such as Parkinson’s disease, specific cancers, and Type 2 diabetes. Seek Medical Opinions: If your diagnosis isn’t presumptive, you’ll need compelling medical evidence, including expert opinions linking your condition to herbicide exposure. Work With a Legal Advocate: Navigating VA appeals alone can feel like navigating a maze. Partnering with a lawyer experienced in VA claims maximizes your chance of success. Why Choose Comerford Law Office? With decades of experience helping veterans and their families, Comerford Law Office is deeply committed to getting you the compensation and justice you deserve. We offer compassionate, personalized representation that makes a difference. From thoroughly reviewing your claims to assembling the strongest possible case, we’ll stand by your side every step of the way. Denied claims can be discouraging, but giving up is not an option. Contact us today for a free consultation, and let’s begin reclaiming the benefits that honor your service and dedication to our country. You don’t have to face this fight alone. We’re here for you.

Is There a Connection Between Agent Orange Exposure and Type 2 Diabetes?

Agent Orange, a tactical herbicide used extensively during the Vietnam War, has been linked to numerous health issues among veterans. One significant condition that has garnered attention is Type 2 diabetes. Understanding this connection can help affected veterans seek necessary medical and legal assistance. At Comerford Law Office, we aim to provide veterans with the information and support they need. The Connection Between Agent Orange and Type 2 Diabetes Exposure to Agent Orange has been scientifically linked to Type 2 diabetes. Veterans who served in Vietnam, the Korean Demilitarized Zone, Thai Air Force bases, or on C-123 aircraft are particularly at risk. The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) recognizes this link and has included Type 2 diabetes on its list of conditions that qualify for a presumptive service connection. This means that veterans do not need to provide evidence linking their diabetes directly to their military service; proof of service during a qualifying period and medical records demonstrating the condition’s severity are sufficient. Statistics and Health Implications Type 2 diabetes affects approximately 10% of adults in the United States, with 95% of these cases being Type 2. While often associated with lifestyle factors such as obesity and inactivity, other risk factors like exposure to Agent Orange play a crucial role. Veterans exposed to this herbicide face an increased risk of developing not only diabetes but also secondary conditions like hypertension, coronary artery disease, renal dysfunction, peripheral neuropathy, and depression. Legal Precedents and Benefits The VA provides several benefits for veterans suffering from illnesses linked to Agent Orange exposure, including monthly monetary compensation, free medical treatments, and additional benefits for secondary service-connected disabilities. These benefits aim to support veterans financially and medically, acknowledging the profound impact of their service-related health issues. For instance, veterans with diabetes caused by Agent Orange exposure may qualify for Total Disability Individual Unemployability (TDIU) benefits if their condition prevents them from maintaining gainful employment. Additionally, veterans’ families may also receive benefits if birth defects are linked to the veteran’s exposure. Accessing Resources and Support If you believe your Type 2 diabetes stems from Agent Orange exposure, it’s vital to seek legal and medical support promptly. Begin by gathering your medical records and proof of service. Consulting with a highly experienced veterans benefits lawyer can help navigate the VA claim process and ensure you receive the benefits you deserve. Contact Comerford Law Office At Comerford Law Office, LLC, we are dedicated to advocating for veterans’ rights. Our experienced team, led by Attorney James R. Comerford, understands the challenges veterans face and is committed to helping you secure the benefits you’re entitled to. If you have questions about VA benefits or need assistance with your claim, contact us for a consultation. Let us help you navigate this complex process and achieve the support you need for a better quality of life.

Common Disabilities Linked to Service in the Vietnam War

Service in the Vietnam War took a significant toll on the physical and mental health of many veterans. The effects of this service often linger, manifesting as various disabilities that can dramatically affect a veteran’s daily life. Understanding these disabilities, their causes, symptoms, and impacts is essential to ensuring that affected veterans receive the care and benefits they need and deserve. Common Disabilities Linked to Service in the Vietnam War Post-traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) PTSD is a mental health condition triggered by experiencing or witnessing a terrifying event. Among veterans, especially those from the Vietnam War, PTSD can result from exposure to combat, witnessing death or injury, or other traumatic experiences. Symptoms may include flashbacks, nightmares, severe anxiety, and uncontrollable thoughts about the event. This potentially debilitating condition can significantly impair a veteran’s ability to function in their daily life. Illness from Agent Orange Exposure Agent Orange was a herbicide used during the Vietnam War to clear forest cover. Exposure to this chemical has been linked to several health problems, including various cancers, heart disease, and Parkinson’s disease. Symptoms and severity can vary widely, but all significantly affect the quality of life for impacted veterans. Gulf War Syndrome This syndrome refers to a collection of potentially disabling symptoms experienced by veterans of the Gulf War, which occurred shortly after the Vietnam War. Symptoms can include fatigue, headaches, joint pain, indigestion, insomnia, dizziness, respiratory disorders, and memory problems. Despite its name, Gulf War Syndrome can also affect Vietnam War veterans due to similar environmental exposures. Traumatic Brain Injury (TBI) TBI is a significant head injury that affects the brain’s normal functioning. In veterans, TBI can occur from combat-related incidents, such as explosions or falls. Symptoms can include headaches, fatigue, memory problems, mood changes, and difficulty with concentration. TBI can have a profound influence on a veteran’s ability to work or perform daily tasks. Other Physical Impairments Physical impairments such as loss of hearing, vision, or limb are common among veterans. These disabilities can result from combat injuries, exposure to loud noises, or accidents during service. Each of these impairments can significantly impact a veteran’s mobility, independence, and quality of life. How Comerford Law Office Can Help At Comerford Law Office, LLC, the needs of veterans and their families are placed at the forefront. Attorney James Comerford, a member of the National Organization of Veterans Advocates (NOVA), has a proven devotion to protecting the rights of disabled veterans and helping them acquire the benefits they deserve. From helping veterans understand the VA benefits available to them, assisting with the application process, or appealing a denial of benefits, Comerford Law Office is here every step of the way. Our firm navigates the new legacy VA appeals process for disability claims, which now includes options for Supplemental Claims, Higher-Level Review, or Board Appeal. The Comerford Law Office works diligently to ensure that veterans receive the compensation they need in a timely manner. Contact Us If you or a loved one served in the Vietnam War and are now dealing with a disability due to that service, you don’t have to navigate this journey alone. The Comerford Law Office, LLC, is committed to fighting for the benefits you rightfully deserve. Contact us today to start the process towards better support and care.